SmartyKat Instincts 3-Pack HappyNip Tricky Tea Bags Cat Toys, Contains Catnip & Silvervine - Multicolor, 3-Pack

$5.24

Compare at 11 stores

Jackson Galaxy Gotcha! Cat Wand Toy - Interactive Cat Toy, Feather Wand

$15.99

Compare at 3 stores

Catstages Crunchy Pickle Kicker Dental Catnip Cat Toy

$5.59

Compare at 41 stores

Ethical Pets 52084 Wool Mouse Willie Catnip Toys

$6

Compare at 36 stores

Kats'N Us Rabbit Fur Cat Toy Wand - Furry Mouse with Bell, Interactive Toy Mice for Cats, Cat Entertainment Wand Toy - Grey 2 Inch Mouse

$13.99

Compare at 2 stores

Ethical Pets 52084 Wool Mouse Willie Catnip Toys

$6

Compare at 37 stores

Woolbuddy Cat Toy - Cat Sushi Toy, 8pcs, Wool Cat Toy for Boredom & Stimulating, Cute Interactive Cat Toys for Indoor Cats, Self Play Cat Kitten Toys, Cat Chew Toy, Cat Enrichment Without Catnip

$16.99

Compare at 4 stores

Kitty Kick Stix 15" Original Catnip Kicker Toy (Set of 2), Handmade in USA by Cat Lovers, Interactive Natural Cat & Kitten Toy, Packed with 100% Potent Catnip for All Breeds (Unicorn Cats)

$19.79

Compare at 3 stores

Blue Q Existential Kitty Catnip Cat Toy. Premium Organic Catnip Grown in The USA, 100% Cotton Pouches, Kitty Graphics Sure to Delight Every Cat-Keeper.

$9.99

Compare at 25 stores

Interactive Cat Toys Ball Fast Rolling in Pouch, Motion Activate Chirping Cat Toy Hide and Seek Mouse Catching Game (Blue)

$29.99

Compare at 25 stores

SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys - Gray/Cream, Set of 10

$5.92

Compare at 35 stores

Pioneer Pet Nip Nibblers Catnip Toy – 3 Pack – Catnip Filled Toys For Indoor Cats -Teething Toy For Kittens That Bite And Chew

$4.99

Compare at 33 stores

Yeowww Pollock Fish Catnip Toy

$12.02

Compare at 36 stores

Catstages Dental Banana Catnip Cat Chew Toy

$4.99

Compare at 22 stores

Barn Yarn Hand Knit Wool Cat Toy, Stuffed with Organic Catnip

$15.45

Compare at 9 stores

Cosmic OurPets 100-Percent North American Catnip Filled Chili Cat Toy-Hot Stuff (Interactive Cat Toy, Catnip Toys for Cats, Cat Chew Toy, Catnip Toys)

$8.05

Compare at 36 stores

Catstages Loaf Kicker Catnip Toy and Dental Toy for Cats Bread Themed Funny Catnip Stuffed Kicker Toy, Tan

$5.99

Compare at 9 stores

SmartyKat Skitter Critters Value Pack Catnip Cat Toys - Gray/Cream, Set of 10

$5.92

Compare at 35 stores

15" Catnip Cat Kicker Toys/Kitty Kick Sticks/Cat-Nip Kick Sticks (Camo) (Kickers Filled with 1 oz Premium Canadian Catnip)

$13.49

Compare at 7 stores

KONG Artz Cats - Crackling Cat Toys with Catnip, Ribbon and Tail (Kahlo/Picasso)

$12.99

Compare at 17 stores